Pinellas Wants to Walk Away From Weedon Island. You Have Until 5PM Monday to Say Otherwise.

The county’s proposed FY2027 budget would end Pinellas County management of Weedon Island Preserve and Shell Key Preserve, and eliminate lifeguards at Fort De Soto and Sand Key. Commissioners see the budget presentation Tuesday, August 11. Public comment closes at 5PM Monday.
If you live in Pinellas County
Submit your comment here: https://comment.pinellas.gov/
If you live outside Pinellas County
Submit your comment here: https://www.mypinellasclerk.gov/Home/Finance#1639309-bcc-meetings
Out-of-county comments matter more than people assume. Weedon Island draws visitors, students, researchers, and paddlers from across Tampa Bay and well beyond it. If you drive in from Hillsborough, Manatee, or Pasco to use this preserve, say so. Regional use is part of the case.
What is being proposed
Pinellas County is staring down a $42 million budget shortfall heading into the coming fiscal year. County leadership has attributed the gap largely to new unfunded state mandates, including required increases to public safety and law enforcement pension contributions, and every county department was directed to cut.
Parks and Conservation Resources put forward its list. On it: the elimination of county management at Weedon Island Preserve and Shell Key Preserve, and the removal of the lifeguard program at Fort De Soto and Sand Key.
The stated savings for all of it is about $847,000 in FY2027.
That number deserves to sit on the page by itself for a second. Against a $42 million gap, cutting Weedon Island, Shell Key, and every county lifeguard closes roughly two percent of it.
Why Weedon Island was picked
The reasoning offered is technical. Weedon Island and Shell Key are owned by the State of Florida. Pinellas County maintains and manages them under agreement. Since the county does not hold title, the argument goes, the county does not have to carry the cost.
Weedon Island has been managed by Pinellas under a 50-year lease since 1995. That lease exists because then-Commissioner Barbara Sheen Todd fought for it, specifically out of concern that the state was not adequately protecting the site. Documents reviewed by the St. Pete Catalyst indicate that lease can be terminated on six months’ notice, or at the beginning of any fiscal year in which the county does not appropriate money for its upkeep.
Read that again. The lease does not have to be formally cancelled. It can simply be allowed to lapse by not funding it. A budget line disappears and a thirty-year stewardship agreement quietly goes with it.
Staff at the preserves would be reassigned rather than laid off. What happens to the preserves themselves is the open question, and nobody in the current proposal has answered it.
What is actually at stake
Weedon Island Preserve is 3,700 acres of mangrove forest, estuary, and uplands on Old Tampa Bay. It protects the largest contiguous estuarine wetland in Pinellas County. It is also one of the most archaeologically significant sites in Florida, holding cultural heritage sites spanning thousands of years of human occupation, including the excavation site of the Weedon Island canoe.
On top of that ecological and cultural value sits the part most residents actually touch: the Cultural and Natural History Center, the boardwalks and observation tower, the paddling trails, the guided programs, the school field trips, the volunteer corps, and the research partnerships with regional universities.
Friends of Weedon Island President Bill Fehring has warned that withdrawing county support would threaten the preserve’s survival as a heritage site, noting there is no guarantee the state would provide equivalent support, and that abandoning the county program would likely mean losing most or all of the benefits the preserve currently provides Pinellas residents.
University of Tampa professor Kendal Jackson made the same point from the research side: county management is what protects the cultural heritage sites there, and it is the primary mechanism through which the public gets access to them at all.
The preserve does not close on paper. It just stops being staffed, stops being programmed, stops being interpreted, and stops being watched. Which, for a site with irreplaceable archaeological deposits and open water access, is its own kind of closure.
This is not settled
The important thing for residents to understand is that this proposal originated with county administration, not with the elected commissioners, and it has not been voted on.
Commissioner Vince Nowicki has said publicly he does not support the cuts and that there are other places to tighten. Commissioner Kathleen Peters, whose district includes Weedon Island, has called it a true gem for Pinellas County while framing the cuts as difficult but necessary given the pending homestead exemption amendment. Commissioner Brian Scott has expressed dismay while pointing to the recurring pressure from Tallahassee. State Representative Linda Chaney has said she will advocate at the state level for Weedon Island funding.
Parks Director Paul Cozzie has stated directly that these reductions are not final and remain under review as part of the budget approval process.
Translation: this is exactly the window where public comment matters. The budget presentation is Tuesday, August 11. The final budget vote is expected in September.
What to do, and by when
All comments must be submitted by 5PM Monday to be included ahead of the budget presentation.
If you live in Pinellas County
Submit your comment here: https://comment.pinellas.gov/
If you live outside Pinellas County
Submit your comment here: https://www.mypinellasclerk.gov/Home/Finance#1639309-bcc-meetings
Out-of-county comments matter more than people assume. Weedon Island draws visitors, students, researchers, and paddlers from across Tampa Bay and well beyond it. If you drive in from Hillsborough, Manatee, or Pasco to use this preserve, say so. Regional use is part of the case.
What to actually say
Keep it short and make it yours. Form letters get counted. Personal ones get read.
A few things worth including:
- Your name and where you live. Commissioners weigh whether you are a constituent.
- Your specific connection to Weedon Island. A program you attended, a field trip your kid took, a morning you paddled the mangrove trail, research you conducted, volunteer hours you logged.
- The math. $847,000 against a $42 million shortfall is roughly two percent of the problem, in exchange for permanently surrendering a thirty-year stewardship agreement and a state-significant archaeological site.
- The irreversibility. Lifeguards can be rehired next year. A lapsed 50-year lease and unmonitored cultural heritage sites are a different category of decision.
- Ask for a specific alternative. Request that commissioners direct staff to identify replacement savings elsewhere, or pursue the state funding partnership Rep. Chaney has offered to advocate for, before eliminating the preserve line entirely.
Be civil. These are difficult decisions being made under real constraints imposed from Tallahassee, and the commissioners hearing from you are not the ones who proposed this.
Then forward this to three people who have walked that boardwalk.

Source reporting: Peter Wahlberg, St. Pete Catalyst, “County proposing major cuts to its Parks and Rec budget,” August 7, 2026.


